YOUR LIFE. YOUR BUSINESS. YOUR OPTIONS.
What can we help you protect?
INDEPENDENT. LOCAL. HERE FOR YOU.
More choices.
A team in your corner.
Insurance should make sense for your life. At Barrett Hill Insurance, we help you compare available options and understand the coverage you’re choosing.
-
Options from multiple carriers
As an independent agency, we can compare coverage across the companies we represent.
-
Help with the details
Talk through limits, deductibles, and questions with someone who knows insurance.
-
Rooted in your community
Serving customers from Gainesville and Buford, with Georgia roots going back to 1996.
HEAR FROM OUR CUSTOMERS
Local people. Real experiences.
A&R Drywall Solutions
5 days ago
Conner was extremely helpful throughout the entire process of purchasing my commercial insurance. He kept me updated every step of the way, was always easy to reach, and promptly answered all of my questions. He took the time to explain everything clearly and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. I truly appreciate his professionalism, communication, and excellent customer service. Highly recommend!
Roberto Alba
2 weeks ago
Dexter Mapp
2 weeks ago
Lanier Sailors
2 weeks ago
Connor England has been awesome to work with! He brought my insurance down and was very personable. He did a great job communicating throughout the whole process and explained things where they wrre easy to understand! Would recommend to any and everyone!
Whitney Mote
2 weeks ago
I worked with Connor England, and he provided exceptional service. I received quotes fast, he answered all my questions, and he provided knowledgeable recommendations, while keeping my budget in mind. I ended up saving over $2,000 per year.
A Nava
3 weeks ago
Paul Drew
1 month ago
Heather Vinson was amazing in her knowledge in what she does. I honestly wouldn’t go anywhere else.
Coffee shop guy
1 month ago
Jenni T
1 month ago
Michelle Westbrook has been amazing to work with. She always listens to my needs and does her best to find me the best option with the lowest cost. She's very quick with response time. Thanks Michelle for always helping me and my family!
SN Fambrough
1 month ago
Michelle has been my trusted insurance agent for years, and she consistently sets the gold standard for professional excellence.
Beyond being responsive, efficient and knowledgeable, Michelle is just a wonderful, kind and empathetic human being who is a joy to work with. If you want an agent who treats you like a person rather than just a policy number, do yourself a favor and call Michelle today!
Chris Roshaven
2 months ago
johnny wilson
2 months ago
Bone Magic
2 months ago
10/10 would recommend Connor to anybody very helpful and answered all my questions
Liz Adolf
2 months ago
Michelle was so kind and patient helping me find the right insurance! She was so quick responding to me and was able to answer every question I had. I’m going to recommend her to every person not wanting to go through the annoying hassle of insurance shopping
Jessica Andrade
2 months ago
Thank you Lenica for all your help!
Tina Howard
2 months ago
Connor England was extremely helpful and made the process of switching easy!
Diego Valdés
2 months ago
Josh Karoly
3 months ago
Connor was patient and understanding regarding my insurance quote needs. He worked with me over a period of days finding the best fit for my situation. Highly recommended Connor!
Tracy T Richardson
5 months ago
Over the years I have obtained personalized service with Michelle. Thank you for the coverage on all our vehicles and always being there for the family. We appreciate you Michelle..remarkable customer service
Elijah Taylor
6 months ago
Michelle Westbrook is always a pleasure to work with! She will quickly find the best pricing! She takes care of everything from start to finish. 10/10! Highly recommend!!!
Howard Guest
7 months ago
Easy knowledgeable young man got me just as good a deal as other collectitable car insurance without all the restrictions.
Samuel Ogbonna
9 months ago
I had a great experience working with Michelle to get a plan for my new car. Working with her was pleasant, transparent and productive as I felt fully empowered throughout the process.
Rich4335
11 months ago
William Hill, the CEO, made my life significantly easier getting me the same coverage for almost 100$ a month cheaper than the quote from the exact same insurance company. He was professional and quick to respond to my emails and got me a better deal all within a week. Really appreciate the work on his part and the rapid response from his company. Thank you William Hill.
Robert Leffew
11 months ago
Was able to get over double coverage on auto and better coverage on a homeowner policy thanks to this team for the same or less price than what I had. Very thankful for Connor and the company.
Jackie Cronic
1 year ago
I have had insurance with Hill Insurance for years. What a great group. I highly recommend them.
Matthew
1 year ago
The owner William Hill has Made the process of acquiring home insurance stress-free.
You can tell he’s been in the business a long time, and is extremely educated and experienced.
He took the time to walk me through how everything works, and the coverage that I will most likely want in my policy.
Through the whole process, I felt extremely taken care of and educated on the points that are most important to my decision.
He’s been kind and courteous, and I feel confident in working with him and the Hill insurance agency team.
Torah Yarberry
1 year ago
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Michelle went above and beyond in helping me with my commercial insurance policy. As pricey as the market is in the trucking industry, she really put in the extra work to find me the best rates available. I truly appreciate her effort, knowledge, and dedication. She made a stressful process much easier. Highly recommend!
Tonya Scott
1 year ago
Mr. Hill saved us money while simultaneously increasing the amount of coverage we received. I had requested an increased coverage amount on our home. He never tried to upsell us on anything we didn’t need and provided multiple options that worked for us. Always responds in a timely manner. I work night shift and one time he responded to an email I sent him at 2 o’clock in the morning. Definitely not expected but appreciate the above and beyond service. 10/10 recommend.
Roy Larsen
1 year ago
I was in a bind to find new homeowners insurance and didn't think I would be able to reduce my cost at all. That's until I thankfully called Barrett Hill Agency. I had the pleasure of dealing with Annie Novak. Annie is professional, informative and and very responsive. I not only was bale to switch, I saved around $1000 from what I was paying to AmFam. Making the decision to reach out and see what a local agent could offer, proved to be a big win!
Gwynneth Harrington
1 year ago
Simon Hill with Hill Insurance provided a fast, competitive quote with great customer service!!! We have a new insurance agent -Thank you Simon!
Hill Commercial Solutions LLC
2 years ago
Thank you for all of your hard work and dedication! Our experience with Barrett Hill Insurance has been nothing short of amazing!
Chris Novak
2 years ago
I cannot say enough great things about Barrett Hill Insurance and their incredible Agent, Annie Novak (no relation)! From the moment I reached out with my inquiry, I was met with professionalism, kindness, and a genuine willingness to help.
The Annie went above and beyond to ensure that all my questions were answered and that I fully understood my policy options. Annie took the time to explain everything in detail, making sure I felt confident in my decisions. Not only was she knowledgeable, but she also showed true empathy and patience, making the entire process smooth and stress-free.
What truly sets Barrett Hill Insurance apart is their commitment to their customers. They handled my requests with speed and efficiency, keeping me updated every step of the way. I never once felt like just another number—every interaction felt personal and sincere.
It's rare to find a company that genuinely cares about its clients the way Barrett Hill Insurance does. If you're looking for an insurance provider that prioritizes customer satisfaction and delivers top-notch service, look no further! I highly recommend them to anyone in need of reliable coverage with an outstanding support team.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Five stars all the way!
Tiffany Moore
2 years ago
I got my home and auto coverage at a lower rate! Michelle and the Barrett Hill Team were very professional and courteous.
Terry Seehorn
2 years ago
Saved hundreds on auto insurance and the process was quick and amazingly easy. Barrett was friendly, responsive, and attentive.
Ron Ciccarone
2 years ago
Great company to work with
Mindie DeMaagd
2 years ago
Steven Kleinheinz
2 years ago
Easy and friendly to talk too.
Mackenzie Thompson
2 years ago
The best agency ever! Simon found me the best deal and was super helpful.
Lee Goldberg
2 years ago
Have been using them for over 15 years. Always fast and friendly! I've had a couple of problems with insurance companies in the past, got dropped because I needed a roof, lost 2 cars in the same year and Hills made sure I was covered. Have referred all my friends and family to them.
Heather Lambertson
2 years ago
What an incredibly smooth experience with the best outcome possible! I could not ask for a better experience and agent!
Kendall Johnson
2 years ago
Barrett is awesome!
Dale Ann D'Agata
2 years ago
John Spry sr
2 years ago
Suzanne
2 years ago
** 2026 Update: still a happy customer. Michelle is still going above and beyond!
Barrett Hill was recommended to me by a neighbor. My experience has been wonderful since the first phone call. Michelle Westbrook has been very pleasant, helpful, and knowledgeable!
I would definitely recommend Michelle and Barrett Hill Insurance Co.!
Brittany Lewin
2 years ago
Kris Rogers
2 years ago
I want to thank Barrett for all he as done for me. I had a tough journey acquiring Workmen’s Comp insurance for my business for one reason or another. Finally I contacted Barrett Hill and within a couple days he work out a policy that fits my needs. Now I am able to take my business forward in the direction I needed to. I am truly grateful! I recommend this agency tremendously.
Zackary White
2 years ago
Excellent experience working with Barrett! I would highly recommend!
Phllip Keeney
2 years ago
Pleasant experience from day one.
Michelle was great…explained everything,answered all questions I had..
Rico Pappillion
2 years ago
Russ Lomas
2 years ago
Barrett was able to find a solution to our insurance needs that saved us a lot of money. A pleasure to work with him on this. Highly recommended him and Barrett Hill Insurance for your insurance needs.
Jose Luis Lira Davila
3 years ago
Mike M.
3 years ago
Great team of people. They have great customer service.
Bettina Cain
3 years ago
Mr. William Hill was wonderful. Unfortunately for me, I procrastinated and waited to renew my car insurance. I was able to email him outside of the listed business hours, and he called me that same day and had me in a great auto policy within the hour. I am grateful that he was there to assist me.
Caleb Frazier
3 years ago
Gloria cortes
3 years ago
Excellent customer service! Michelle Westbrook is absolutely fantastic! Knowledgeable and sweet. Thank you so much for calling me back!
Torie Navy
3 years ago
John Spry sr
3 years ago
Very knowledgeable. Listen to my needs. And found insurance I can afford
Bethany Taylor
3 years ago
I had the best experience with Michelle! She is very professional and knows what she's doing. She found the best prices and did it quickly. I have sent my friends her info because it was so pleasant! Thank you!
Lynn Jordan
3 years ago
I have been the happiest with this insurance company. They are extremely professional and personable. I can't say enough great things about Sheila Burns! I feel like she is a part of my family. Thank you so much for being there.
M Black
3 years ago
Barrett is great! He answered all of my questions, made sure that I had the best coverage for my home and vehicle, looking out for my best interest, as if we were family. Responsive and knowledgeable! Great experience! I will continue to refer him to others.
Jah-Mai Davidson
3 years ago
Barrett Hill is awesome! He looks out for all of his clients!
He takes his time explaining the options so that our clients can appreciate what homeowners insurance is all about.
Thank you Barrett!
Janet Starley
3 years ago
Excellent service. Every member of the team handled my request with professionalism.
Karen C
3 years ago
I called several insurance agencies on behalf of my Aunt. She needed to find more reasonably priced home and auto insurance. Simon was wonderful. He spent a whole afternoon checking different insurance companies, looking for the best rates with the best coverage for the price. We were thrilled when he was able to find her a great yearly rate. Both he and his Dad were friendly, competent and informative. We highly recommend this agency and appreciate it's personalized service.
Jimmy Collier
3 years ago
The service is great.
Kimberly Johnston
3 years ago
Barrett is always prompt and on point! We appreciate his hard work! Best insurance guy in the state of Georgia!!
Naveed Mughal Mohsin
3 years ago
One of the best experiences i have had with this agency! Honest and upfront about rates.
Simon Hill was very friendly and advised me on what i need to do in order to get better rates and was very patient with me through the the whole process.
Nice agency and very accomodating.
Sonia Atchison
3 years ago
I have been working with Michelle for over 18 years as a client she is the reason why I am still a client, she goes over and beyond and treats each person with EXTREME professionalism.. Thank you Michelle for ALL YOU DO
Alicia Smith
3 years ago
I have been with Barrett for 12 years and I wouldn’t want anyone else to handle my insurance affairs.. if you need a dedicated team.. this is the company to get you where you need to be.
Sebaz
3 years ago
Barrett was on top of his game and was extremely helpful. I would highly recommend.
Caroll Atkins
3 years ago
Michelle is knowledgeable, prompt, patient and personable. It is always a pleasure to work with her on any new business or issue I may have. I would refer her anytime.
Gwendolyn Tutt
3 years ago
When my homeowners insurance increased to a point that was no longer affordable, I called Barrett Hill Insurance and received a call back from Michelle Westbrook. She was very helpful in connecting me with a more reasonable company, even calling me on her own time to make sure I had the new policy. My mortgage company did not properly transfer the policy and when I became aware of the situation I was so stressed out and frustrated. I spent over an hour and a half on the phone with various representatives from the company and was finally connected to Michelle, who immediately straighten out the situation. Michelle is very professional and caring. She put me at ease right away and took charge of my concerns and problem. She is patient, personable and very knowledgeable of the insurance business. I am so happy to have her as an agent and Barrett Hill is very fortunate to have her as an employee.
Savalas Hill
4 years ago
The agent Michele Westbrook was very helpful in getting me insurance. And she walked me through each step. And answered any questions I had. I highly recommend her for all your insurance needs ...
Donald Mullikin
4 years ago
Michelle was very helpful and work tirelessly to get me the insurance I needed for a tractor I’m buying. She even worked past closing time to get me what I needed. She does not normally work with this type of product but that did not deter her. She kept me informed of her progress all along the way. I can now purchase my tractor on Thursday. Great Job Michelle.
Isabela Visan
4 years ago
Highly recommending Ms Michelle W. We have been working with her for over 10 years and had a great experience. We have various insurance needs and she goes above and beyond every time. We can count on her prompt assistance, kindness and professionalism with every phone call or email.
A sincere thank you for all you do!
Blessings!
Kimberly Raybon
4 years ago
Michelle Westbrook and her mother, Elizabeth, have been handling our family's insurance for over 20 years. I'm so happy they're working with Barrett, who has been our insurance company for several years. They take care of us and we appreciate it!
Chad Richardson
4 years ago
Mr. Barrett, Shelia and related staff are highly reliable and attentive to the myriad of needs I have had over the years with six children, cars, RV's, toys, homeowners and other insurance needs. I have had a couple of problems with their insurance providers in the past and they immediately addressed and resolved the issue each time. It can't get any better than that.
Ariel Elion
5 years ago
Barrett has been handling all of my insurance needs, inclusive of car and home for the past few years. He is always very prompt and responsive in communication and thorough in finding the best deals to meet your needs. I highly recommend he and his team for your insurance needs as well. I am grateful for his agency and their service!
FAMILIAR FACES. PERSONAL HELP.
Meet your local team.
W. Barrett Hill
Owner & Principal Agent
Michelle Westbrook
Agent
Simon Hill
Agent
Annie Novak
Agent
Connor England
Agent
LET’S FIND YOUR OPTIONS
Start with a few details.
Select the coverage you’re interested in, then tell us a little about yourself. Our team will review your request and follow up.
Submitting a request does not bind or change insurance coverage. Please leave sensitive personal and payment information out of general comment fields.
Get in Touch
Two local offices. One team ready to help with your insurance questions.